Skip to content
The Mayeri Law Firm Call

How to appeal an Alabama Department of Revenue assessment

A final assessment can be appealed within 60 days of mailing or personal service, whichever is earlier: to the Alabama Tax Tribunal, which requires no payment, or to circuit court, which requires payment, a bond or a net-worth showing. A preliminary assessment is answered with a written petition for review to the Department within 30 days (Ala. Code § 40-2A-7).

The path, step by step

Step What happens Deadline Source
Preliminary assessment The Department proposes an amount after reviewing a return, or when no return was filed. A written petition for review within 30 days of mailing or personal service, whichever is earlier Ala. Code § 40-2A-7(b)(1)a, (b)(4)a
Conference When the petition is timely, the Department schedules a conference to hear your objections and try to agree. — § 40-2A-7(b)(4)a
The Department decides It withdraws the assessment or makes it final, with interest and penalties computed to the date of entry. If it does neither within 5 years, you may appeal as if it were final § 40-2A-7(b)(4)b–c
Final assessment The amount stands unless you appeal. 60 days from mailing or personal service, whichever is earlier (the period was 30 days until October 1, 2025) § 40-2A-7(b)(5); Act 2025-343 (House Bill 505)
Appeal to the Tax Tribunal No payment, bond or filing fee. Filed by U.S. mail, a delivery service or hand delivery, never by email or fax. Within the 60 days Tax Tribunal
Or appeal to circuit court The notice of appeal is filed with both the Department’s secretary and the circuit court clerk. The taxpayer also pays, posts a 125% bond or letter of credit, pledges securities at 200%, or shows net worth of $250,000 or less, counting the home. Within the same 60 days. If the court finds the payment, bond or net-worth condition unmet, it orders it met and allows 30 days after service of that order. § 40-2A-7(b)(5)b–c
Or pay and claim a refund The final assessment and its interest are paid in full, before or with a refund petition to the Department. By the later of 3 years from the date the return was filed or 2 years from payment; deemed denied after 6 months without action, unless extended by written agreement; a denial can be appealed within 2 years § 40-2A-7(c)
After a Tribunal decision Either side may ask the Tribunal for a rehearing, or appeal to circuit court. Rehearing (optional): within 15 days of the order’s entry. Circuit court: within 30 days of entry, or of the order on rehearing if one was sought Ala. Code § 40-2B-2(l)(5), (m)(2); r. 887-X-1-.07(2)
As of October 21, 2026

What is the difference between a preliminary and a final assessment?

A preliminary assessment is the Department’s proposed bill. You answer it with a written petition for review that sets out your specific objections, and the Department then schedules a conference. You cannot take a preliminary assessment to the Tax Tribunal unless it was entered more than 5 years ago and is still open (Tax Tribunal FAQ).

A final assessment is the Department’s formal decision, mailed to your last known address or served in person. It is the one you appeal (§ 40-2A-7(b)(4)d, (b)(5)). If you file no petition for review, the Department may make the preliminary assessment final as computed.

Should you choose the Tax Tribunal or circuit court?

The Tax Tribunal suits a taxpayer who wants a decision without paying first. There is no filing fee, and a Tax Tribunal judge decides without a jury. Hearings are informal when the taxpayer appears alone or with a representative who is not an attorney (Ala. Admin. Code r. 887-X-1-.04(5)).

Within the same 60 days, the notice of a circuit court appeal must be filed with both the Department’s secretary and the circuit court clerk. The taxpayer must also meet the payment, bond or net-worth condition (§ 40-2A-7(b)(5)b). These steps are jurisdictional: an appeal that misses them “shall be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.”

There is one safety valve. If the court finds the payment, bond or net-worth condition unmet, it must order the taxpayer to meet it, and the taxpayer then has 30 days after service of that order. A late notice of appeal has no such cure (§ 40-2A-7(b)(5)c).

A Tribunal decision can itself go to circuit court within 30 days. If the taxpayer appeals at that stage, the same payment, bond or net-worth condition applies within those 30 days (Ala. Code § 40-2B-2(m)).

The full comparison, with the legal effect and tax effect of each route, is on the page for Alabama Department of Revenue disputes and Tax Tribunal appeals.

A worked example

Suppose the Department mails a final assessment on Monday, March 1, 2027. Counting 60 days from the day after mailing reaches Friday, April 30, 2027.

Alabama’s general rule for counting days excludes the first day and includes the last. When the last day is a Sunday, a legal holiday or a day the office is closed as the law allows, the next working day counts instead (Ala. Code § 1-1-4).

For a Tax Tribunal appeal, a 60th day that falls on a Saturday generally moves to the next working day. The Tribunal’s office is closed on weekends (Tax Tribunal), and the Department’s timely-mailing rule says Saturdays, Sundays and state holidays are generally excluded (Ala. Admin. Code r. 810-1-5-.01(1)(b)). Had the assessment been mailed on Tuesday, March 2, 2027, the 60th day would be Saturday, May 1, and a Tribunal appeal would be due Monday, May 3.

The Department’s appeal-rights page speaks of “a weekend or U.S. holiday,” but its rule counts Alabama state holidays, not holidays that are federal only (Alabama Department of Revenue). For a circuit court appeal, Alabama’s civil procedure rule excludes a Saturday last day when a statute does not say how to count days (Ala. R. Civ. P. 6(a)). Whether it governs that appeal, which must also be filed with the Department, is not settled, so it is safer to file before the weekend.

People generally file well before the last day and keep proof of when they mailed or delivered the appeal.

The tax side

An appeal does not freeze the numbers. A final assessment includes interest and penalties computed to the date it is entered (§ 40-2A-7(b)(4)b). Interest on unpaid Alabama tax generally runs from the tax’s due date at the federal underpayment rate, which is the federal short-term rate plus 3 percentage points (Ala. Code § 40-1-44(a); IRC § 6621(a)(2)).

If you pay and later win, the refund carries interest from the date of overpayment, with listed exceptions (§ 40-1-44(b)). Penalties “shall be waived upon a determination of reasonable cause,” and the taxpayer bears the burden of showing it (Ala. Code § 40-2A-11(h)).

Paying first makes the most sense when you want to stop interest from building up on the amount in dispute while the case is decided. The trade-off is cash: the money stays with the Department until a refund is granted, if it is. The final assessment plus interest must be paid in full before or with the refund petition (§ 40-2A-7(c)(1)).

Mistakes to avoid

  • Leaving the notice unopened. The 30 and 60 days run from mailing or personal service, whichever is earlier, not from the day you open the envelope.
  • Emailing or faxing a Tribunal appeal. The Tribunal accepts neither. It takes appeals by U.S. mail, a delivery service or hand delivery.
  • Trusting old guidance. Pages that say 30 days for a final-assessment appeal, or $100,000 for the circuit court net-worth test, are out of date. The statute now says 60 days and $250,000.
  • Mailing a Tribunal appeal on the last day. The Tribunal judges timeliness by the postmark or hand-delivery date. A private carrier’s package counts on the day it is handed over only if the service is on the IRS’s designated list. With any other service, such as UPS Ground, it counts when it arrives. In March 2026 the Tribunal dismissed an appeal sent by UPS Ground on the last day because it arrived the next morning (Docket No. INC. 25-0309-RC).
  • Relying on an ordinary postmark. After the postal service changed its postmark procedures in December 2025, the Department advised mailing early and using certified mail or a counter postmark (Alabama Department of Revenue).
  • Counting on a postmark for a circuit court appeal. Alabama’s timely-mailing statute does not apply to “the filing of a document in … any court” (Ala. Code § 40-1-45(d)(1)).

When to call a lawyer

Many people talk to a lawyer when a preliminary assessment arrives, because the petition for review and the conference are the first chance to correct the Department’s numbers before they become final. A small assessment may cost less to pay than to dispute. Robert Mayeri handles Alabama Department of Revenue disputes and Tax Tribunal appeals.

Questions people ask

Can I appeal a preliminary assessment to the Tax Tribunal?

Not usually. You answer a preliminary assessment with a written petition for review to the Department within 30 days. If 5 years pass without the Department withdrawing it or making it final, you may then appeal it as if it were final (Ala. Code § 40-2A-7(b)(4)c).

Does the Tax Tribunal charge a filing fee?

No filing fee is charged, and appealing there requires no payment or bond. Appeals go by U.S. mail, a delivery service or hand delivery, never by email or fax. The Tribunal judges timeliness by the postmark or hand-delivery date (Tax Tribunal).

A private carrier’s package counts on the day it is handed over only if the service is on the IRS’s designated list. With any other service, such as UPS Ground, it counts when it arrives (r. 810-1-5-.01(8)).

What happens at the conference after a petition for review?

The Department and the taxpayer present their positions, discuss any errors or omissions, and try to agree on changes. If the Department still upholds the assessment in whole or in part, it may make it final. The 60-day appeal clock then starts when the final assessment is mailed or personally served, whichever is earlier (§ 40-2A-7(b)(4), (b)(5)).

Have an assessment in hand?

Call (205) 266-7728 with the date it was mailed and the tax periods it covers, or send a short outline through the contact page. Please leave out confidential details until a conflict check is complete.

Schedule a consultation

Sources