Tax attorney or CPA: which do you need?
Attorneys, CPAs and enrolled agents (individuals enrolled to practice before the IRS) may all represent you before the IRS (31 C.F.R. § 10.3). A CPA or enrolled agent is usually enough for returns, planning and routine notices. A tax attorney fits better when a dispute may reach court, criminal exposure is possible, or the answer turns on a legal document.
Who usually handles what
| Situation | Usually enough | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Preparing returns, keeping the books, planning the year | A CPA or an enrolled agent | This is return and accounting work, with no dispute to resolve. |
| An IRS letter about a return a CPA or enrolled agent prepared | Often that CPA or enrolled agent | CPAs and enrolled agents in good standing may represent clients before the IRS (31 C.F.R. § 10.3(b)–(c)). |
| An Alabama assessment appealed to the Alabama Tax Tribunal | You, a CPA or an attorney | Alabama law lets the taxpayer appear, or be represented by an attorney admitted in Alabama, an accountant licensed in Alabama, or another authorized representative (Ala. Code § 40-2B-2(n)(1)). |
| An appeal to an Alabama circuit court | You, or an attorney | People may attend to their own claims (Ala. Code § 34-3-6(c)). Appearing as an advocate for someone else before a court is the practice of law, reserved to licensed attorneys (§ 34-3-6(a), (b)(1)). |
| A case in the U.S. Tax Court | You, or someone admitted to practice there | You may file on your own. A representative must be admitted there; non-attorneys must pass the Court’s written examination and are generally sponsored by two members of its bar (Tax Court Rule 200). |
| Possible fraud or a criminal investigation | An attorney, first | The federal privilege for tax advice from a CPA does not apply in criminal matters (IRC § 7525). |
| A business sale, an estate plan or a divorce | Both skills | Drafting the documents is legal work and the numbers are tax work, and each one changes the other. |
Rules as of October 21, 2026.
What can a CPA do when you have a tax problem?
A great deal. Under the Treasury rules, attorneys, CPAs and enrolled agents may all represent taxpayers before the IRS, attorneys and CPAs by filing a written declaration (31 C.F.R. § 10.3). That covers most audits, notices and collection questions handled with the IRS itself.
CPAs can also appear at the Alabama Tax Tribunal, the independent body that hears appeals from the Alabama Department of Revenue. By statute, any taxpayer, business or individual, may appear or be represented by an attorney admitted in Alabama, an accountant licensed in Alabama, or another authorized representative (Ala. Code § 40-2B-2(n)(1)). The Tribunal may also allow an out-of-state attorney or accountant in a particular matter, and a representative needs its power of attorney, Form 2848ATT (Tax Tribunal FAQ).
The limit comes at the courthouse door. In Alabama, appearing as an advocate for someone else in a proceeding before a court is the practice of law (Ala. Code § 34-3-6). The U.S. Tax Court admits attorneys in good standing, and may admit others who pass its written examination and are sponsored by members of its bar (Tax Court Rule 200).
When is a tax attorney the better choice?
Three situations point to a lawyer:
- The dispute may reach a court. An appeal of an Alabama final assessment (the Department of Revenue’s formal finding of tax, interest and penalty due) can go to circuit court instead of the Tax Tribunal. A federal deficiency (tax the IRS says is owed beyond what the return showed) can be disputed in the U.S. Tax Court.
- Criminal exposure is possible. If the IRS or the state might suspect fraud, what you say, and to whom, matters from the first conversation. Communications with a lawyer for legal advice can be protected by the attorney-client privilege. The federal privilege for CPAs does not reach criminal matters (IRC § 7525(a)(2)).
- The answer depends on a legal document. Contracts, wills, trusts, operating agreements and divorce settlements decide who owes what. Drafting them is legal work.
Is what you tell a CPA privileged?
Partly. Under federal law, tax advice from a “federally authorized tax practitioner,” such as a CPA practicing before the IRS, can be protected. The protection matches attorney-client confidentiality, but only to the extent the communication would be privileged if made to an attorney (IRC § 7525(a)(1)).
That protection has limits: it covers only advice within the practitioner’s authority to practice before the IRS (IRC § 7525(a)(3)(B)). It can be claimed only in noncriminal tax matters before the IRS and in noncriminal federal court tax cases brought by or against the United States (IRC § 7525(a)(2)). It does not cover written communications promoting participation in a tax shelter (IRC § 7525(b)).
Because § 7525 applies only in those federal settings, it does not cover an Alabama Department of Revenue or Tax Tribunal matter. Alabama has no accountant-client privilege of its own: its rules of evidence and its accountancy law create none, and the Tax Tribunal applies only “the rules of privilege recognized by law” (Ala. R. Evid. 501; Ala. Code § 40-2B-2(k)(4)). A CPA must keep client information confidential, but that duty gives way to a valid subpoena or a summons a court will enforce (Ala. Admin. Code r. 30-X-6-.04(1)).
Lawyers sometimes bring in an accountant to help them understand a client’s numbers. In United States v. Kovel, 296 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1961), a federal appeals court held that the attorney-client privilege can extend to that accountant when the communication is made in confidence “for the purpose of obtaining legal advice from the lawyer.” No privilege exists if only accounting service is sought, or if the advice sought is the accountant’s rather than the lawyer’s.
Kovel is a Second Circuit decision that other courts may or may not follow. Alabama’s own rule extends the attorney-client privilege to “a person employed by the attorney to assist the attorney in rendering professional legal services,” and the Advisory Committee’s notes to that rule cite Kovel (Ala. R. Evid. 502(a)(4)). Arrangements like this are often called Kovel arrangements, and whether one holds up depends on the facts.
How do attorneys and CPAs charge?
Federal rules limit contingent fees (fees that depend on the outcome) for attorneys, CPAs and enrolled agents alike in most IRS matters (31 C.F.R. § 10.27). Exceptions include an IRS exam or challenge of an original return, certain amended returns or refund claims filed within 120 days of an exam notice, interest and penalty claims, and court cases. In Alabama, the accountancy board’s rules also bar CPAs from charging contingent fees for preparing original or amended tax returns or claims for refund (Ala. Admin. Code r. 30-X-6-.04(2)(b)).
At The Mayeri Law Firm, if the firm is engaged, you receive the steps and the fee in writing before work begins.
When does one person with both licenses help?
Some decisions are legal and financial at once: selling a business, settling an estate, dividing a business in a divorce. A change to the documents changes the tax, and a change to the tax plan changes the documents.
Robert Mayeri is licensed in Alabama as an attorney and as a certified public accountant. Because he holds both licenses, he reviews the legal documents and the financial records behind them himself.
The tax side
Where a dispute is heard can change when you pay. Once you petition the U.S. Tax Court, the IRS generally may not assess the disputed deficiency or start collecting it until the Court’s decision becomes final (IRC § 6213(a)). Interest on any tax finally owed still runs from the last date set for payment until it is paid (IRC § 6601(a)).
In Alabama, a final assessment can be appealed to the Tax Tribunal without paying it or posting security. The deadline is 60 days from the date the final assessment was mailed or personally served, whichever was earlier. An appeal to circuit court instead requires one of these within the same 60 days (Ala. Code § 40-2A-7(b)(5)):
- Payment of the amount on the final assessment.
- A bond or letter of credit for 125% of that amount, or a pledge of securities for 200%.
- Proof that the taxpayer’s net worth, including the home, is $250,000 or less.
Alabama also charges interest from the tax’s due date (Ala. Code § 40-1-44(a)). Choosing the forum is a legal decision with a cash effect, which is why it helps to weigh both together.
When to call a lawyer
People usually bring in a lawyer when a dispute may reach court, a criminal inquiry is possible, or the answer turns on a contract, a will or another legal document. A routine notice about a return a CPA or enrolled agent prepared usually stays with them. See how Mr. Mayeri handles IRS and Alabama tax disputes.
Questions people ask
Can my CPA represent me at the Alabama Tax Tribunal?
Yes, if the CPA is licensed in Alabama; the Tribunal may allow an out-of-state CPA in a particular matter. Any taxpayer, business or individual, may appear or be represented by an attorney admitted in Alabama, an accountant licensed in Alabama, or another authorized representative (Ala. Code § 40-2B-2(n)(1)). A representative needs the Tribunal’s Form 2848ATT (Tax Tribunal FAQ).
Can a CPA represent me in the U.S. Tax Court?
Yes, if the CPA has been admitted to practice before the Tax Court. A CPA who is not also an attorney must pass the Court’s written examination, is generally sponsored by two members of its bar, and needs the Court’s approval (Tax Court Rule 200). You may also handle your own case (U.S. Tax Court: starting a case).
Is what I tell my CPA privileged?
In noncriminal federal tax matters, a CPA’s tax advice is protected to the same extent it would be if it came from an attorney (IRC § 7525). It is not protected in criminal matters, in written communications promoting a tax shelter, or before the Alabama Department of Revenue or the Tax Tribunal.
In those Alabama matters, a CPA must keep what you say confidential, but no privilege shields it from a valid subpoena or a summons a court will enforce.
Should I hire both?
For a business sale, an estate or a divorce, often yes, because the documents and the tax numbers depend on each other. Many people keep their CPA for returns and bring in an attorney for the legal work. Mr. Mayeri holds both licenses, so he can look at both sides of the same decision.
Not sure which you need?
Call (205) 266-7728 with a brief outline of the matter. Mr. Mayeri will advise whether it fits and what the next step would be. Please leave out confidential details until a conflict check is complete.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. § 7525, confidentiality privileges for taxpayer communications, checked October 21, 2026
- 31 C.F.R. § 10.3, who may practice before the IRS, checked October 21, 2026
- 31 C.F.R. § 10.27, fees, including contingent fees, checked October 21, 2026
- U.S. Tax Court Rule 200, admission to practice and U.S. Tax Court, starting a case, checked October 21, 2026
- Ala. Code § 34-3-6, who may practice as attorneys, checked October 21, 2026
- Ala. Code § 40-2B-2, Alabama Tax Tribunal and Alabama Tax Tribunal, frequently asked questions, checked October 21, 2026
- Ala. Admin. Code ch. 30-X-6, Alabama State Board of Public Accountancy, checked October 21, 2026; rule 30-X-6-.04(1) checked October 26, 2026
- Alabama Rules of Evidence 501, privileges recognized only as provided and 502, attorney-client privilege, checked October 26, 2026
- United States v. Kovel, 296 F.2d 918 (2d Cir. 1961), checked October 21, 2026
- 26 U.S.C. § 6213, restrictions on assessment of deficiencies and § 6601, interest on underpayments, checked October 21, 2026
- Ala. Code § 40-2A-7, assessments and appeals and § 40-1-44, interest on Alabama tax, checked October 21, 2026